In a 2017 story that captured the intersection of internet curiosity and real human struggles, a Zillow listing in South Carolina once dubbed the “nightmare house” revealed a far more touching and complex tale than the ghostly theories it initially inspired. The listing became notorious for its cryptic message about an upstairs tenant who was not to be disturbed, sparking widespread speculation and intrigue.

Background of the Mysterious Listing

Located in Cayce, just outside of Columbia, the property was listed with a peculiar caveat that the upstairs apartment could not be shown under any circumstances. The ad stated, “Buyer assumes responsibility for the month-to-month tenancy in the upstairs apartment. The occupant has never paid, and no security deposit is being held, but a lease is in place. (Yes, it does not make sense; please don’t bother asking.)” This mysterious note led to the home being called a ‘diamond in the rough’ and it quickly went viral, amassing over 1.7 million views and becoming Zillow’s most shared ad of 2017.

The Real Story Behind the “Tenant”

The real story, however, is not one of horror but of humanity and enduring friendship. The so-called “secret tenant” is Randall McKissick, a 70-year-old once-celebrated artist who has faced considerable hardships. McKissick, who suffered from a divorce, eviction, and an anxiety disorder, found it difficult to adapt to the digital age, which drastically affected his artistic career. His works once celebrated in galleries worldwide, could no longer compete in the new market dynamics.

Randall’s longtime friend, Michael Schumpert Sr., offered him the upstairs apartment rent-free to help him during these tough times. Tragically, after Schumpert Sr. suffered a severe injury from a car accident in December 2016, his son, Michael Jr., penned the mysterious ad in an effort to sell the house, hoping to resolve the family’s uncertain financial future without displacing McKissick.

The Community’s Reaction and the Future

The local newspaper, The State, played a crucial role in uncovering and sharing McKissick’s story, revealing the so-called nightmare house to be a sanctuary for a man whose contributions to the art world had been formidable. Described by journalist Jeff Wilkinson as a “sensitive genius,” McKissick expressed his gratitude for the support and shared his ongoing love for art, hoping to find the spark to paint again.

The Schumpert family is currently exploring alternative housing options for McKissick, who lives with his three beloved cats. The family faces financial challenges, especially considering McKissick’s anxiety issues and his deep connection to his current home.

The Power of Narrative and Community Support

This story underscores the power of narrative and community in our digital age. What started as an online curiosity became a moving account of friendship, challenges, and the human spirit. It reminds us that there are real lives and stories behind every viral story.

The full story is available on The State’s website for those interested in reading more about this compelling tale. Read the full story here.